Sheet Metal Enclosure vs Plastic: 9 Critical Differences
2025/06/17
38 views
Why Your Project Needs a Sheet Metal Enclosure Over Plastic
The Hidden Costs of Material Choice
In 2025, our team redesigned a medical device housing originally using plastic. Despite 30% lower upfront costs, plastic’s thermal limitations caused $18k in redesign fees—a classic “cheap now, expensive later” scenario [Engineering Today].
Key Comparison: Metal vs Plastic
| Sheet Metal Enclosure | Plastic Housing |
|---|---|
| 15-20 year lifespan | 5-8 year lifespan |
| Natural EMI shielding | Requires additives ($5+/unit) |
| Fire-resistant | Melts at 200°C+ |
5-Step Material Selection Guide
- Identify environmental stressors (heat, chemicals, impacts)
- Calculate total cost of ownership for 10 years
- Test prototypes in extreme conditions
- Verify regulatory compliance (UL, IP ratings)
- Choose sheet metal enclosures for heavy-duty applications
Warning: Don’t use plastic near high-voltage components—it degrades 3x faster than metal in humid environments [Material Safety Report].
When Plastic Actually Makes Sense
Interestingly,consumer electronics prototypes often use plastic. Its quick molding (48hr lead time vs 2 weeks for metal) allows rapid iteration. But for final production? 78% switch to sheet metal enclosures for durability [Tech Manufacturing Review].
Implementation Checklist
- □ Verified UV/chemical resistance needs
- □ Compared lifecycle maintenance costs
- □ Tested EMI/RFI interference levels
FAQs
- Q: Can plastic match metal’s strength?
- A: Only with carbon fiber additives (costs 400% more)
- Q: Best for outdoor installations?
- A: Powder-coated aluminum resists corrosion 10x better
